Brazil Indigenous Win at Supreme Court

Brazil Indigenous Win at Supreme Court

Brazil Indigenous Win at Supreme Court. By Vic Bishop.

In a world of never-ending bad news for nature and Mother Earth, some good news has at last come to the Indigenous people of Brazil who recently won two separate court rulings validating their rights to land.

At issue was the attempt to block the titling of lands long-held by indigenous people, a move which would have allowed more land to be sold out from under native peoples to corporations seeking to drill for oil or deforest the land for the production of palm oil, cattle ranching, or mining.

Cintamani May 2018 Half Price

Marked with scandal, Brazil’s current president was recently formally accused of corruption for taking bribesfrom and pandering to a large contingency of mining and agribusiness interests.

As part of this scandal, President Temer made significant concessions to the business sector which would included, “rollbacks on indigenous rights, reduction of environmental protected areas, legalization of land grabbing and support for gutting legislation on environmental licensing of development projects – not to mention billions in budget amendments earmarked to specific members of congress.

Brasilian President Michel Temer

Brasilian President Michel Temer

Brazil Indigenous Win

This type of official contempt for natives and the sacredness of land in the region are shockingly common, and it is not surprising that this type of action would come from the highest offices in the land.

Never-the-less, the recent cases went all the way to the Brazilian Supreme Court, and were highly contentious, bringing many thousands of people out to protest in the wake of the rulings.

Protests in Brazil orTheir Own Land Rights

Protests in Brazil orTheir Own Land Rights

Brazil Indigenous Win

As plaintiff in both cases, the government of Mato Grosso state claimed that portions of the Xingu Indigenous Park and territories occupied by the Nambiquara and Parecis people were initially “vacant lands” belonging to the state government, and so their appropriation by the federal government in order to grant titles to indigenous tribes was illegal and deserving of financial indemnification.

The Supreme Court ruled unanimously in both cases that overwhelming evidence exists to confirm the status of the disputed areas as traditional native territories, rendering subsequent land claims, and claims for indemnification, null and void.

Brazil Indigenous Win

Amazon Watch

In these cases, the government itself was attempting to seize land from natives by using a contentious legal argument that said that indigenous people had to prove that land in question was occupied by them in October of 1988, or the law would decree that the land was vacant and therefore available for seizure by the government.

Then, of course made available to big agribusiness for development.

This attempted legal loophole was just rejected by the supreme court.

In reaching its decision, the Court rejected elements of a contentious legal argument known as “marco temporal“, used by the government of Michel Temer and conservative rural elites in attempts to blockade the titling of indigenous ancestral territories.

The legal argument claims that indigenous lands should only be demarcated – titled to indigenous peoples – if clear proof exists that they were occupied by those communities in October 1988, the ratification date of the current Brazilian constitution.

Brazil Indigenous Win

Amazon Watch

The greater issue here is the demarcation of native lands which allows large tracts of forested and natural land to be protected under the stewardship of indigenous tribes.

At a time when deforestation of the Amazon continues unabated, and ever-greater investment into the extraction of Amazonian natural resources by China and other nations threatens to accelerate the destruction of the Amazon, any legal victory as this is a huge win.

Furthermore, there is a long history of human rights abuses in these regions, and a legal victory as momentous as this is quite rare.

“The Supreme Court sent a very clear message that the rights of indigenous people are fundamental and must be respected.” ~Luís Enrique Eloy, legal counsel to the Articulation of Brazil’s Indigenous Peoples (APIB)

At stake in Brazil and other South American nations is the survival of the world’s largest remaining rainforests, or, the lungs of the earth.

While dense with natural resources, these areas also contain major stores of the world’s natural biodiversity in animals and plant life.

Many equate the destruction of the Amazon with planetary suicide, because of the disruption to the world’s eco-system that would certainly follow the destruction of the Amazon.

For Native Americans the story was different, before the lawsuits it was well planned to extint them.

The deforestation of North America is the main cause, whatever the academics says, of the immense disasters that constantly affect that area of the Planet.

Disclosure News

Message to Brazil

Message to Brazil and its Population from the Platinum Fleet, it is addressed to specific people but it is valid all over the world.

Make a Donation in Bitocoin


  • 2019 Server Cost Support - 2400 € 20% 20%

Support Disclosure News Italia

We are working hard, and every day, to keep this blog. Like you we are fighting for the truth. If you want to work with us you are welcome, please email us! The blog costs are at our expense, advertising reimburse us very marginally so if you like our work and find it useful buy usacoffee clicking the donation button below that will direct you to your PayPal. We need the help of people like you!


Pin It on Pinterest